A Form 4 is filed within two business days of a company insider — an officer, a director, or a holder of more than ten percent of the stock — changing their position in the shares. All 9 filings in this group are Form 4s for First Internet Bancorp.
The difficulty with reading these filings as a group is that a single form type covers transactions that mean entirely different things. An executive spending their own money to buy stock and an executive having shares withheld to pay tax on a vesting grant both appear as a Form 4. Every filing below is therefore tagged with the nature of the underlying transaction, taken from the transaction code reported on the form itself.
Across the 9 insider filings shown, the breakdown is 8 compensation award and 1 open-market purchase. 1 of them involved a discretionary open-market trade; the rest are compensation and administrative mechanics.
Form 4
Compensation award
Tax / Compensation Filing
2026-05-19
INBK insider Form 4 filed for equity award, exercise, or tax withholding
Bade Aasif M. (Director) filed a Form 4 covering compensation-related activity such as stock awards, option exercises, conversions, or tax withholding. These filings are usually neutral.
Shares were granted as compensation rather than purchased. No cash changed hands, so the filing reflects a pay decision by the company, not a judgement about the price.
Transactions reported on this filing
| Code |
Nature |
Shares |
Price |
Value |
A |
Compensation award
|
2,416 |
— |
— |
Filing: Form 4 (Insider Transaction)
Insider: Bade Aasif M. (Director)
Shares: 2,416
Form 4
Compensation award
Tax / Compensation Filing
2026-05-19
INBK insider Form 4 filed for equity award, exercise, or tax withholding
KEACH JOHN K JR (Director) filed a Form 4 covering compensation-related activity such as stock awards, option exercises, conversions, or tax withholding. These filings are usually neutral.
Shares were granted as compensation rather than purchased. No cash changed hands, so the filing reflects a pay decision by the company, not a judgement about the price.
Transactions reported on this filing
| Code |
Nature |
Shares |
Price |
Value |
A |
Compensation award
|
2,416 |
— |
— |
Filing: Form 4 (Insider Transaction)
Insider: KEACH JOHN K JR (Director)
Shares: 2,416
Form 4
Compensation award
Tax / Compensation Filing
2026-05-19
INBK insider Form 4 filed for equity award, exercise, or tax withholding
Dee Ann C. (Director) filed a Form 4 covering compensation-related activity such as stock awards, option exercises, conversions, or tax withholding. These filings are usually neutral.
Shares were granted as compensation rather than purchased. No cash changed hands, so the filing reflects a pay decision by the company, not a judgement about the price.
Transactions reported on this filing
| Code |
Nature |
Shares |
Price |
Value |
A |
Compensation award
|
2,416 |
— |
— |
Filing: Form 4 (Insider Transaction)
Insider: Dee Ann C. (Director)
Shares: 2,416
Form 4
Compensation award
Tax / Compensation Filing
2026-05-19
INBK insider Form 4 filed for equity award, exercise, or tax withholding
WOJTOWICZ JEAN L (Director) filed a Form 4 covering compensation-related activity such as stock awards, option exercises, conversions, or tax withholding. These filings are usually neutral.
Shares were granted as compensation rather than purchased. No cash changed hands, so the filing reflects a pay decision by the company, not a judgement about the price.
Transactions reported on this filing
| Code |
Nature |
Shares |
Price |
Value |
A |
Compensation award
|
2,416 |
— |
— |
Filing: Form 4 (Insider Transaction)
Insider: WOJTOWICZ JEAN L (Director)
Shares: 2,416
Form 4
Compensation award
Tax / Compensation Filing
2026-05-19
INBK insider Form 4 filed for equity award, exercise, or tax withholding
Raines Michele L. (Director) filed a Form 4 covering compensation-related activity such as stock awards, option exercises, conversions, or tax withholding. These filings are usually neutral.
Shares were granted as compensation rather than purchased. No cash changed hands, so the filing reflects a pay decision by the company, not a judgement about the price.
Transactions reported on this filing
| Code |
Nature |
Shares |
Price |
Value |
A |
Compensation award
|
2,416 |
— |
— |
Filing: Form 4 (Insider Transaction)
Insider: Raines Michele L. (Director)
Shares: 2,416
Form 4
Compensation award
Tax / Compensation Filing
2026-05-19
INBK insider Form 4 filed for equity award, exercise, or tax withholding
Fenech Joseph A. (Director) filed a Form 4 covering compensation-related activity such as stock awards, option exercises, conversions, or tax withholding. These filings are usually neutral.
Shares were granted as compensation rather than purchased. No cash changed hands, so the filing reflects a pay decision by the company, not a judgement about the price.
Transactions reported on this filing
| Code |
Nature |
Shares |
Price |
Value |
A |
Compensation award
|
2,416 |
— |
— |
Filing: Form 4 (Insider Transaction)
Insider: Fenech Joseph A. (Director)
Shares: 2,416
Form 4
Compensation award
Tax / Compensation Filing
2026-05-19
INBK insider Form 4 filed for equity award, exercise, or tax withholding
Christian Justin P. (Director) filed a Form 4 covering compensation-related activity such as stock awards, option exercises, conversions, or tax withholding. These filings are usually neutral.
Shares were granted as compensation rather than purchased. No cash changed hands, so the filing reflects a pay decision by the company, not a judgement about the price.
Transactions reported on this filing
| Code |
Nature |
Shares |
Price |
Value |
A |
Compensation award
|
2,416 |
— |
— |
Filing: Form 4 (Insider Transaction)
Insider: Christian Justin P. (Director)
Shares: 2,416
Form 4
Open-market purchase
Insider Buying
2026-02-26
INBK insider Fenech Joseph A. (Director) bought 1,000 shares (~$19.8K)
Fenech Joseph A., listed as Director at First Internet Bancorp, reported an open-market purchase of 1,000 INBK shares in a Form 4 filing. Insider buying is often treated as a bullish signal because company insiders are committing their own capital.
The insider bought shares on the open market with their own money. This is the only Form 4 category that requires a discretionary cash outlay at the prevailing price.
Transactions reported on this filing
| Code |
Nature |
Shares |
Price |
Value |
P |
Open-market purchase
|
1,000 |
$19.83 |
$19.8K |
Filing: Form 4 (Insider Transaction)
Insider: Fenech Joseph A. (Director)
Shares: 1,000
Est. Value: $19.8K
Form 4
Compensation award
Tax / Compensation Filing
2026-02-03
INBK insider Form 4 filed for equity award, exercise, or tax withholding
Lovik Kenneth J. (Executive Vice President & CFO) filed a Form 4 covering compensation-related activity such as stock awards, option exercises, conversions, or tax withholding. These filings are usually neutral.
Shares were granted as compensation rather than purchased. No cash changed hands, so the filing reflects a pay decision by the company, not a judgement about the price.
Transactions reported on this filing
| Code |
Nature |
Shares |
Price |
Value |
A |
Compensation award
|
1,116 |
$21.79 |
$24.3K |
Filing: Form 4 (Insider Transaction)
Insider: Lovik Kenneth J. (Executive Vice President & CFO)
Shares: 1,116